Monday, June 19, 2023

The Linguistics Wars: Chomsky, Lakoff and the Battle Over Deep Structure by Randy Allen Harris: Second Edition: Book Review

[This is a reread of sorts.  I read the first edition, and reviewed it on this blog on June 14, 2021.   The second edition is actually a lot different than the first edition in many places, but in other places similar to the first edition.  So sometimes this felt like a reread, sometimes it felt like a completely new book.]

On My Shelves: December 11, 2022
Started: March 27, 2023
Finished: June 18, 2023





April 2, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.i-xvi, p.1-36
April 9, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.36-80
April 16, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.80-104
April 23, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.104-106
April 30, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.106-158
May 7, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.158-184 
May 14, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.184-202
May 21, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.202-246
May 28, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.246-270
June 4, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.270-334
June 11, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.334-392
June 18, 2023 The Linguistics Wars p.392-421

Playlist for the second edition HERE


Playlist for both editions HERE


Addendum

Started: Marvel Horror Lives Again!

Sunday, June 18, 2023



 


Books (39 pages this week)
Comic Books (Comic Books don't count towards weekly page counts)
Revolutions Season 5: Spanish American Wars of Independence 2nd Listening From: 5.10- War To The Death To: 5.13- The Letter From Jamaica(from Revolutions Podcast)

Videos from this Week:
Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Ugly Truth by Jeff Kinney: Book Review https://youtu.be/ximBwoPCsfc

For more information about what this is and why I'm doing it, see HERE.
Finished: The Linguistics Wars: Chomsky, Lakoff and the Battle Over Deep Structure by Randy Allen Harris: Second Edition 



Friday, June 16, 2023

Sorting Activity for Reporting Verbs

(TESOL Worksheets--Reporting Verbs)
Google: docs, pub
[This is a sorting activity I used for Unit 6, Listening Skill: Understand Reporting Verbs p.98 from Reflect Listening & Speaking 5.  The choice of reporting verbs reflects the textbook, as does the categorization.  In the textbook this information is given to the students in a grammar box, but the teachers book suggested that this information could be make more engaging for students by having them categorize the verbs on their own first, and then check their answers with the grammar box.  And I agreed.  So I developed this little worksheet.  
The word cards are cut up and shuffled before class.  In pairs, students place the word cards  in the correct box.  
I think this activity could also stand on its own as an independent resource, so I'm posting it here as well.]

Report a fact or observation

Report an opinion

Report advice

Report a request for action



























Report a fact or observation

Report an opinion

Report advice

Report a request for action

explain


agree

advise

call for

mention


believe

argue

demand

observe


claim

propose

encourage

point out


estimate

recommend


report



suggest




Thursday, June 15, 2023

So, I've just deleted all progress on Duolingo's Vietnamese course, and gone all the way back to the beginning of the course.
Again.
The last time I restarted the course from scratch was back in November.  At that time, Duolingo had redesigned their website to make their courses more linear.  (For more information on that redesign, see this news article from August 2022: Duolingo’s redesign has some fans up in arms. Its CEO says it’s not turning back.  That article is from August, but my experience was that the redesign didn't hit the Vietnamese course until November.)
At the time the redesign hit, Duolingo shuffled how its lessons were arranged.  They attempted to preserve my progress by placing me midway on the new course.  (I had been roughly halfway through the old course before the redesign.)  But I quickly realized that because of the reshuffling, I had missed out on some units, and I was frustrated at having missed some key lessons.  So I just deleted all my progress and restarted.
...actually I've lost track of how many times I've deleted all my progress on Duolingo and restarted.  I think I first started Duolingo back in 2015 or 2016.  (I wrote about my experiences on Duolingo back in 2017, but I had been using it for a while before then.)  I would study it for several months, then get busy at work and miss a few days, and then just give up on it.  And then I would come back to it several months later, and realize I had forgotten half the words I had learnt, and decide to just restart the whole course from the beginning.  I must have restarted Duolingo 2 or 3 times, even before the infamous redesign hit in November 2022.

...but anyway, two days ago, I just got notified that Duolingo had changed its Vietnamese course again.
This time it looks like it's the content of the course they've changed, not the structure.
Again, they attempted to preserve my place on the course, by placing me roughly a quarter of the way through the new course.  (I had been about roughly a quarter of the way through the old course.)  But, after a few lessons, I quickly realized that there were a lot of new vocabulary words on the new course that I had missed out on because they'd occurred in earlier lessons.  So I just restarted the course again.

The introductory lessons from the redesigned course are full of vocabulary that I had never learned on the old course, so I think I'm glad I restarted.
Gone, as far as I can see, are all the old nonsense sentences that Vietnamese Duolingo used to be so famous for.  ("Bee and Coffee", "The Goat is at the Ferris Wheel", "The glove is at the station", "you are that chicken" etc)



I don't know, maybe these strange sentences will start popping up again a little bit further down the course.  But they're not in the introductory lessons.
The new course actually looks like it has useful sentences and vocabulary instead--how to order drinks, how to introduce yourself, how to communicate at work and school, etc.

So, maybe it will be a better course.

I just hope that this time, I will be able to complete the course before they redesign it again, and screw up all my progress.  We'll see.  
Anyway, follow my progress on Duolingo HERE.   The quizlet which I use to consolidate all of my Duolingo vocabulary is HERE.  And the last times I mentioned Duolingo on this blog are HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE and HERE.  

Sorting Activities

(TESOL Ideas--Activities That Can Be Used For Any Grammar Point)

Sorting activities is something I mentioned before in my workshop: Activities That Can Be Used With Any Grammar Point.

I'll repeat here what I wrote in that workshop:
Sorting Activity (Materials: Worksheet with several sentences) (Preparation: Prepare worksheet--10 minutes)
  Used for when you want to draw a distinction between two grammar points--e.g. past simple versus present perfect.  Since, arguable, all grammar is defined by contrasts (e.g. the present continuous is defined by its contrast with the present simple, the past perfect is defined by its contrast with the past simple) this be used for any grammar point once you think of something to contrast it with. 
Students are given a list of sentences, and have to sort them into different categories.
I've often found sorting activities are useful as a way to get students to notice the grammar function themselves.
I've used this activity several times in the past.  See, for example: